Welcome to our new web site!
To give our readers a chance to experience all that our new website has to offer, we have made all content freely avaiable, through October 1, 2018.
During this time, print and digital subscribers will not need to log in to view our stories or e-editions.
When Eric Enriquez was elected mayor of Las Cruces in 2023, he trailed former city councilor Kasandra Gandara on each round of ballot tabulation until the final round, but that was enough to send Enriquez to the mayor’s office.
The city of Las Cruces adopted ranked-choice voting for its municipal elections in June 2018, with the first election using the system taking place in November 2019. The council vote that approved Ordinance 2861 and implemented the often-misunderstood voting procedure was unanimous. Ranked choice applies only in city elections that include more than two candidates.
Las Cruces was the second city in New Mexico to adopt ranked-choice voting, following Santa Fe.
RCV allows voters to rank candidates in order of preference rather than choosing just one. This process is also known as "instant runoff voting," and the ballot counting is performed in rounds until a candidate wins a majority (over 50%) of the votes.
When filling out a ballot, voters can rank as many or as few candidates as they choose, as they select their first choice, then a second choice, and down the list.
When votes are tallied, any one candidate must reach that magic level of an outright majority to be declared the winner. If no one gets there in the first round of counting, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated, and the count is performed again, with the ballots of those who ranked that person No. 1 redistributed to those voters’ second choice.
The process repeats until someone has 50% of the votes from the candidates still in the running.
As the field of eight candidates was whittled down to one in 2023, Enriquez was the first to get to 50%, but he was running behind Gandara in every round of counting until the point when the candidate who finished third was eliminated. When that candidate’s votes moved to their next-in-ranking candidate, the election swung to Mayor Enriquez.
Greg Smith served two terms on the Las Cruces City Council and ran for mayor six years ago in the first ranked-choice city election in Las Cruces. He was a big advocate for ranked-choice voting.
“I was on the city council when we decided to do that and I was one of the people advocating for it,” Smith said.
He knew the acceptance curve would be difficult as people are slow to adapt to change.
“It’s a little bit like a roundabout,” Smith said. “We know statistically that the traffic circles are safer, and they reduce energy use and that kind of stuff, but people have to adjust to them, and there's a lot of push back at the beginning.”
The council believed the change to ranked choice was an opportunity to increase voter engagement in municipal elections and also elevate positive campaigning. Since city elections are non-partisan, it seemed like a great place for a fresh start.
“I was hoping that ranked choice would demonstrate at the municipal level something that could be happening more at other levels,” he said. “It would make it more democratic in the end. Oftentimes, especially in some of these city elections, you end up with somebody with 30 or 40-something percent. I think it gives more legitimacy to somebody who has won an election when they can say, ‘More than 50% of the voters voted for me.’”
One other factor Smith felt would come into play with ranked-choice voting is an improvement in the positivity in campaigns.
“I thought we as candidates are less likely to trash our opponents because the people who are voting for that person may choose to mark us down as their second or third choice,” he said. “So, it reduces the negative campaigning that goes on, and I felt like negative campaigning has been a particularly obnoxious part of of how campaigns have gone in recent years.”
Smith also feels it gives voters an opportunity to cast a vote for a candidate they really prefer who seems like a long shot.
“Sometimes, people don't vote for the person they want because they don't think they can win,” he said. “You can in good conscience still vote for that person as your first choice and even if he or she does not get enough votes to stay in the running, then your second choice comes into play.”
Another advantage to ranked-choice voting, according to Smith, is that it encourages voters to engage with all the candidates and listen to all of their messages. An individual might know who he wants as a first choice, but who should he rank No. 2, No. 3, and so on. A voter who pays more attention to all the messages might even change her mind on which should be her first choice.
“I'm a big believer in the voters being informed and making conscientious choices, so whatever breaks people out of just sort of automatically voting a certain way, I think helps us be better informed voters,” Smith said.
He feels the city needs to make sure it continues to educate citizens about how the process works. That is the key to taking away the initial pushback.
“There's still people who, with the traffic circles, still stop when they should be going or still go when they need to be stopping,” Smith said. There’s that education, that learning curve, that still needs to happen.”